How Can I Choose a Mattress to Avoid Back Pain?

Last Updated On July 7th, 2024
How Can I Choose a Mattress to Avoid Back Pain?

Key Takeaways

  • Personal Comfort Matters Most: Select a mattress based on your own comfort rather than following generic advice. Opt for a medium-firm mattress that supports your spine while allowing your shoulders and hips to sink slightly for optimal alignment.
  • Consider Mattress Components: Understand the support core (like coils or foam) and comfort layers (such as memory foam or latex) of mattresses. These components affect how well the mattress supports your body and relieves pressure points.
  • Trial and Assess: Take advantage of extended home trials offered by retailers to properly test a mattress. This allows you to evaluate its impact on your sleep quality and back pain over an extended period before making a decision.

Stop us if you know this storya sleep-deprived soul, hunched over their morning coffee, wincing with every movement to their sore back and neck. Sound familiar?

For countless individuals, the quest for a good night’s sleep feels like an endless saga, with back pain playing the seemingly undefeatable villain. Choosing the right mattress can be a game-changer in this nightly battle.

Save $450 On Any Mattress

Plus free shipping

Get $450 OFF Mattresses

A well-suited mattress acts like a silent guardian, cradling the spine and allowing muscles to truly relax. It’s the unsung hero in the fight against back pain.

On the flip side, the wrong mattress? Well, that’s more like a nightly saboteur, leaving its unfortunate owner feeling like they’ve gone ten rounds with a heavyweight champion by morning.

Now, here’s where it gets interesting. Common wisdom might suggest that a mattress as unyielding as a park bench is the ticket to back pain relief. But hold your horses! This one-size-fits-all approach often leads unsuspecting shoppers down the wrong path.

When mattress shopping becomes a necessity (and let’s face it, for many, it’s long overdue), the key is to tune into personal comfort. It’s not about what worked for your best friend or what’s trending in mattress circles. No, this journey is all about finding that perfect match between body and bed.

So, buckle up, dear reader. We’re about to embark on a whirlwind tour of mattress wisdom.

These tips aren’t just dry facts plucked from a manual. Oh no, they’re hard-won insights, culled from the sleep trenches. They’re the pearls of wisdom that could mean the difference between waking up feeling like a superhero or a super zero.

So, grab a cup of tea, settle in (preferably not on that lumpy old mattress), and let’s unravel the secrets to choosing a mattress that will have your back saying “thank you” instead of “ouch.”

Quick Guide: A 30-Second Summary

Best Mattress for Back Pain Overall Amerisleep AS2
Best Mattress for Side Sleepers Amerisleep AS3
Best Latex Mattress Amerisleep Organica

Is It Time for a Mattress Upgrade?

Your bed won’t last forever, so it’s important to know when to replace the mattress. Keep an eye out for telltale signs of wear and tear.

Is there a noticeable dip in the middle, like a king’s ridge? Do you wake up feeling uncomfortable or sore? These are clear indicators that your mattress has outlived its usefulness.

While you might be tempted to try quick fixes like placing boards underneath to combat mattress sagging, these are just temporary solutions. They won’t address the root problem or restore your mattress to its former glory.

If you find yourself resorting to such measures, it’s probably time to start shopping for a new mattress. Remember, a good mattress is an investment in your sleep quality and overall health.

Prioritize Comfort and Good Balance

When picking a new mattress, try to find one that’s both comfy and supportive. A good mattress should feel nice to lie on and also help your back. Many people like Verified Source National Library of Medicine (NIH) World’s largest medical library, making biomedical data and information more accessible. View source medium-firm mattresses because they’re not too hard or too soft.

These let your shoulders and hips sink in a bit, which can stop aches in those spots. Super hard mattresses might seem good for your back, but they can actually hurt.

And a well-supported spine is crucial for waking up free from muscle soreness. The right mattress should make you feel good when you lie down and when you wake up, without any morning pain.

If you do want a firmer mattress, look for one with extra padding on top. This way, you get the firmness for your back but still have some softness for comfort.

Remember, your personal comfort should be the deciding factor in your choice. Don’t be swayed by popular trends or general recommendations. 

Instead, trust your body’s signals. The ideal mattress is simply the one that helps you wake up feeling refreshed and pain-free, regardless of its style or type.

Focus on finding a mattress that meets your specific needs for both support and comfort, a balance that allows your back to relax and recover during sleep

Know Your Mattress Components

Venturing into the realm of mattress shopping can feel like stumbling into a foreign land with its own bewildering language. When shopping, don’t hesitate to ask about these features.

Let’s peel back the layers and demystify the inner workings of these nocturnal havens.

The Support Core: A Mattress’s Backbone

At the heart of every mattress lies its support core, the unsung hero of a good night’s sleep.

For the traditionalists, there’s the classic innerspring system, a labyrinth of coils ready to bounce you into dreamland. But for those seeking a greater level of sophistication, individually wrapped coils offer a covert operation in motion isolation. Both of these options differ in number and arrangement across models.

And completely separate from these two is the world of base foam. These dense foam layers are like the bouncers of the bed, providing a solid foundation that says “No entry” to sagging and premature wear.

High-density polyfoam is a popular choice, offering a firm base that could probably support a small car (though we don’t recommend testing that theory).

The Comfort Layer: A Surface That Lulls

Atop the support core lies a world of comfort layers, each with its own sleep-inducing superpowers:

  • Memory foam, the chameleon of mattress materials, molds to the body like a second skin.
  • Latex, on the other hand, offers a sprightlier embrace, perfect for those who prefer their mattress with a side of bounce.

You’ll find foam tops and padding in various thicknesses, adding comfort to the supportive base.

Remember that the ideal combination of coil count, padding type, and mattress depth isn’t universal – it’s a personal decision. Your comfort should guide your choices in these components, so take the time to test different options and see what feels best for your body.

Finding Your Perfect Sleep Match

When it comes to picking a mattress, your comfort is key. Trust me, I’ve been through the mattress-shopping wringer, and I’ve learned a thing or two.

Here’s my step-by-step guide to help you make the right choice of mattress.

Give it a Real Test

Forget those awkward two-minute lie-downs in the store. They’re about as useful as trying to judge a book by its cover. I once bought a mattress based on a quick in-store test, and boy, was that a mistake.

Now, I always look for retailers offering extended home trials. During my last mattress trial, I kept a sleep journal. It was eye-opening to see how my sleep quality changed over time.

Remember, that initial “ahh” feeling might just be the novelty factor. Give it time to truly know if it’s “the one.”

Think About Temperature

Are you a human furnace? Then you need to prioritize breathability. Otherwise, you might end up with a cheap foam mattress that feels like sleeping on the surface of the sun.

Now, I swear by mattresses with cooling tech. Especially on hot summer nights, when it is a game-changer. If you live somewhere warm or your bedroom turns into a sauna at night, trust me, temperature regulation is your new best friend.

Consider Your Sleep Position

I’m a side sleeper who occasionally flips to my back, and finding the right mattress was like solving a puzzle. Too firm, and my hips felt like they were being jabbed by a fork. Too soft, and my spine curved like a banana. I finally found my Goldilocks zone with a medium mattress that lets my shoulders and hips sink just enough.

If you’re a stomach sleeper, you’ll probably want something firmer to keep your hips from sinking. It’s all about keeping that spine aligned, folks.

Match the Mattress to Your Body

Here’s a hard truth: what works for your 90-pound friend won’t necessarily work for you. For a larger frame, the same mattress can feel like sleeping on a marshmallow. Not fun.

Instead, look for mattresses that support the body’s natural shape. No more waking up and feeling like you’ve been in a wrestling match with the bed.

Consider Motion Isolation

If you share your bed, this one’s crucial. You may have a partner that’s still as windless evening, but many of us have partners that toss and turn , making the bed feel like a boat in choppy waters.

Switching to a mattress with good motion isolation can be life-changing. No more waking up from a partner’s midnight acrobatics or sudden sprint to the bathroom.

Assess Edge Support

Ever sat on the edge of your bed to put on socks, only to feel like you’re sliding off? Been there, done that. And for those with movement disabilities, falling off the bed can a serious concern.

Good mattress edge support is a game-changer there. It’s also helpful if you’re using every inch of your mattress. Two people can sprawl right to the edge without feeling like they’re about to take a tumble off the side.

Evaluate Pressure Relief

If you’ve ever woken up with numb arms or aching hips, you know the importance of pressure relief. Don’t be fooled into thinking it’s all just a part of getting older.

When you have a mattress with proper pressure point relief, you should wake up feeling like you’ve had a gentle full-body massage instead of a fight with the bed.

Consider Allergies

For those of us allergic to what feels like half the planet sometimes, this one is for you. Never let yourself buy a mattress that has you sneezing like it’s pollen season.

Instead, always check for hypoallergenic materials by reading the mattress tag or manufacturer’s specs.

Natural latex and certain types of memory foam can be good mattresses for allergy sufferers. Some mattresses come with removable, washable covers which can help keep allergens at bay, too!

Think About Mattress Depth

From svelte 7-inch numbers to towering 18-inch sleep skyscrapers, mattress depth is a game of “just right.” Deeper isn’t always better, but you don’t want a bed so thin it will wear out within the year, either.

The key is finding that sweet spot where support meets luxury without requiring a step ladder to climb into bed.

Factor in Your Budget

Look, we all want the fanciest, most high-tech mattress out there. But unless you’re sleeping on a pile of cash, you’ve got to be realistic.

Price doesn’t always equal quality. Some of the top-reviewed mattresses out there are mid-range in price. It’s about finding that sweet spot between comfort and cost.

Consult with Healthcare Professionals

Before investing in a new mattress to address your back pain, it’s smart to talk with healthcare professionals who specialize in spinal health and sleep disorders. That way, you get a recommendation just for you instead of the generalized advice you find online.

Experts to consult include:

  • Your primary care physician
  • A specialist like an orthopedist who can assess your back pain
  • Chiropractors
  • Physical Therapists
  • Osteopaths
  • Sleep Specialists

Remember, while standard guidelines are helpful, your back pain might have unique causes or complications. A professional can take into account your medical history, current condition, and sleep habits to give you tailored advice.

Moreover, these professionals can help you distinguish between back pain caused by your mattress and pain that might be indicative of a more serious underlying condition requiring medical treatment.

By consulting with healthcare professionals before making your mattress decision, you’re more likely to find a solution that not only helps with your back pain but also improves your overall sleep quality and health.


Is a firm mattress always best for back pain?

No, a firm mattress isn’t always the best choice for back pain. Many people with back issues actually find medium-firm mattresses more comfortable and supportive.

These mattresses allow your shoulders and hips to sink in slightly while still providing good support for your spine. The key is to find a balance between comfort and support that works for your body.

How can I test a mattress properly before buying?

To test a mattress properly, don’t just lie on it for a few minutes in the store. Look for retailers with good return policies that allow you to try the mattress at home for an extended period, ideally a month or more. This gives you enough time to determine if the mattress truly helps with your sleep quality and back pain.

Remember, the initial comfort of a new mattress might just be a placebo effect. While it’s normal to feel some soreness on a brand new bed for a few nights, if you’re not sleeping well past the first month it’s time to consider returning the mattress.

How often should I replace my mattress?

You should replace your mattress when you notice signs of wear and tear, such as visible sagging in the middle or when you consistently wake up feeling uncomfortable. While there’s no set timeframe, most mattresses last about 7-10 years.

Don’t try to extend your mattress’s life with quick fixes like placing boards underneath – if you’re considering such measures, it’s probably time for a new mattress.

Does my sleep position affect what kind of mattress I should choose?

Yes, your sleep position definitely affects your mattress choice. Side sleepers, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers all put pressure on different parts of their bodies, so they need different levels of firmness and support.

For example, side sleepers often need a softer surface to cushion their hips and shoulders, while stomach sleepers typically need a firmer mattress to keep their hips from sinking too much.

Are memory foam mattresses good for back pain?

Memory foam mattresses can be good for back pain as they mold to your body shape, potentially offering better support. They can help distribute your weight evenly and maintain proper spine alignment.

However, keep in mind that some memory foam mattresses retain heat and may contain more chemicals than other types. If you’re considering a memory foam mattress, look for one with cooling properties if you tend to sleep hot.

How important is mattress temperature for sleep quality?

Mattress temperature is quite important for sleep quality. Many people don’t sleep well when they’re too hot, so keeping cool is crucial for good rest. If you live in a warm climate or your bedroom tends to get warm at night, look for a mattress with breathable materials.

Some mattresses come with cooling technologies that can help regulate your body temperature throughout the night.

What should I look for in terms of mattress components?

When looking at mattress components, pay attention to the support core (often coils or inner springs), the comfort layers (padding on top), and the overall depth of the mattress. The number and arrangement of coils, the type and thickness of padding, and the mattress depth can all affect comfort and support.

However, remember that the ideal combination of these elements is personal. Don’t hesitate to ask about these features when shopping, and prioritize what feels best to you.


Choosing the right mattress is a crucial step in managing back pain and improving your sleep quality. Remember that medium-firm mattresses often provide a good balance of comfort and support for many people with back pain.

However, there’s no one-size-fits-all solution. Focus on your personal comfort, understand the possible mattress components, and consider factors like sleep position and temperature can guide you to the best choice.

Don’t rush your decision—take advantage of in-home trials when possible, and listen to your body’s responses. Investing time in finding the right mattress can lead to better sleep, less pain, and improved overall well-being.

About the author

April Mayer is a sleep expert and writer with a degree in exercise physiology. She has dedicated her career to exploring the relationship between sleep and productivity. Her insightful articles, such as "The Surprising Way Your Mood Might Be Messing With Your Productivity" and "Wake Up to More Productive Mornings," have been featured in reputable publications like Forbes, Greatist, Real Homes, Thrillist, Tom's Guide, and Eat This, Not That. With a passion for helping others lead more productive lives through restful sleep, April offers valuable expertise on foods and vitamins for better sleep. As a trusted member of the Early Bird team since March 2020, she continues to provide informative and well-researched content.

View all posts

Discover the ultimate sleep system

Choose your mattress

Shop top-rated mattresses with proven sleep-boosting materials.

Get a pillow

We have the perfect pillow to pair with your mattress.

Browse Pillows

Pick out bedding

Bring out the best in your mattress with our soft and breathable bedding.

Browse Bedding